6309 Monarch Park Place, Suite 203
Niwot, CO 80503, USA
Phone (303) 443-5060
Toll free (888) 742-5060
Deliver Distribution News to Your Inbox
Sign up below to receive MDM Update, your free weekly distribution news update by email.
Airgas argued that the amendment was invalid under Delaware law and Airgas' Certificate of incorporation because it created two annual meetings in the same fiscal year and illegally shortened terms for current board members. The company also contested the passage of the amendment on the grounds that less than 67 percent of eligible votes were cast in favor of it.
Delaware Chancery Court Judge William B. Chandler ruled against both challenges, citing Delaware law as requiring "no minimum amount of time" between meetings and affirming Air Products' claim that the amendment only requires a simple majority.
In his opinion, Chandler wrote: "Ironically, until April 2010, Airgas's bylaws provided for annual meetings to be held anytime within a five-month window following Airgas's fiscal year – that is, the meeting could be held anytime from April to August. … In April 2010, Airgas amended its bylaws so that its directors could set the annual meeting date at any time and pushed back its annual meeting to September in response to Air Products' hostile threat."
Airgas announced it would appeal the ruling.